those “angry adoptees,” those “bitter birthmothers”


As my thoughts these days have turned to how I’ve changed and how I’m living my life as authentically as I can, no matter what some may think of me, I’m making connections with what those in other types of circumstances have/are going through. What I’ve most recently been accused of doesn’t have a nifty alliteration, but I can make one up that I think the accuser would probably approve of: “crybaby cancer patient.”

We’re a society that loves alliteration, don’t we? We even like it better when the letters line up, as in “angry adoptees” and “bitter birthmothers.” Note the kinds of alliterative business names that make me cringe because they just have to spell one word wrong to make the name cuter: Kuts for Kids, as just one example.

But I digress, as I tend to do. Those “angry adoptees” and “bitter birthmothers” — wow, do they make some people uncomfortable. One way of say, putting them in their place, is to dismiss them with these not-so-nifty alliterative putdowns. Lump them into a category, and you don’t have to deal with them or their craaazy ideas again, do you?

But you see, as I’ve found through everything that I’ve been through, it’s very easy to label someone with “angry,” “bitter,” “whiny,” or “irresponsible.” In fact, it’s a hell of a lot easier than actually listening to that person, I mean really listening and trying to understand or empathize with their truth. Because, once again, it’s something that we can’t easily fix. This society in general, full of “fix-it” people, doesn’t have the patience for problems that can’t be easily fixed. So it’s much easier for some people to simply dismiss or minimize the problems of others, the truths of others. My cancer, while in remission, is in a way, lurking in the background. When I first learned that it had metastasized (soon after I learned I had cancer at all), my oncologist said that she’d “give me x years.” It’s hard for me to live with that in the back of my mind all the time, even though I know she’s not God and I may (and hope to) beat the odds. But you see, my fears, my doubts, make people uncomfortable, and some who can’t deal with it would rather label me as “whiny” or “negative” than face what my reality is.o

In a similar way, the feeling of not belonging, of being abandoned that many adoptees describe makes many people uncomfortable. They can’t “fix” it. So instead of honoring that reality and saying something like “I can’t fix these feelings for you, but I respect and honor your reality and will listen to you,” they often get labeled “angry” or are told to “get over it.” I simply don’t understand that philosophy. I mean, how in the world would I be able to tell someone to “get over” something that I haven’t even been through? Yet some others seem extremely comfortable in doing just that.

As first mothers understand the realities of their situations, the circumstances that lead up to the relinquishing of their babies, they understandably become sad and angry. They feel a loss. And that makes people uncomfortable. Again, it can’t be fixed. So it’s just easier to assign them labels — “bitter birthmothers” being just one of many. Can people instead honor their reality and listen to them, listen to the pain of their lives? Some can; many can’t.

As a “crybaby cancer patient,” I’ve come to understand firsthand how some people react to something that they simply can’t fix. “Just think positively!” “You HAVE been doing well, haven’t you?” “Just keep doing what you’ve been doing and you’ll be fine.” “Oh, breast cancer? That’s nothing these days.” And the worst, from someone I trusted for many years, that I’m “whiny” and “irresponsible.” These messages serve to simply tell me that the person to whom I’ve been speaking isn’t compassionate enough, doesn’t have the empathy to simply listen to my truth and honor it.

And while I tried to listen and be empathetic to adoptees and first mothers before the cancer, I think I understand — in a way — how it feels to be repeatedly dismissed, marginalized, and at the worst, called names by someone who desperately wants to silence me. In similar ways, adoptees and first mothers are repeatedly dismissed, marginalized, and called names by those who desperately want to silence them. Who are SO uncomfortable with their truths that their truths are dismissed.

I can’t “get it” like fellow adoptees or fellow first mothers “get it.” But I “get it” in another way. I get it to the extent that someone not in their shoes can get it. I get how it feels for someone to tell you that what you experience simply isn’t true, I get how it feels for someone to not want to hear your truth, and I get how it feels for someone to so discount your truth that they lash out at you and bring up every single thing they think you’ve done wrong in the past 20 years. I get that. I get how soul-crushing it is to be dismissed by someone of import in your life, although I obviously can’t get it to the extent that fellow adoptees and first mothers do. But I get it, in my own way.

Those adoptees aren’t angry. Or maybe they are, but they have reasons to be angry. They’re more than one emotion. They’re people with as many emotions and situations and ways of handling them as anyone else. The same with first mothers. If they’re bitter, have people stopped to find out why? Have they listened to them, really listened to their stories to discover the reasons behind the feelings of bitterness, loneliness, loss?

I’m not saying to these “angry adoptees” and “bitter birthmothers;”

I know exactly how you feel

because I don’t. How could I? That in itself would be dismissive of their feelings. I’m simply saying that, in my own way, I understand what it feels like to be dismissed and marginalized. I don’t know what it feels like to be an adoptee or a first mother. But I know what it feels like to make people so uncomfortable that labeling you is easier than listening to you.

I feel like I’m babbling . . . and not sure if I’m making sense or saying things “right.”

So let me just say to adoptees and first mothers that I honor your experiences and I’m ready to listen. I may not always know what to say in response . . . but I’m listening and I care. And I think you’re way more than “angry adoptees” and “bitter birthmothers.” No, scratch that. I know you are.

17 thoughts on “those “angry adoptees,” those “bitter birthmothers”

  1. Awesome post.

    How on earth does someone say to you “you’re irresponsible” if you have cancer? Please don’t tell me someone seriously said that.

    “Oh, breast cancer? That’s nothing these days.”

    … what?

    As for the being dismissed part, amen.

  2. Thank you, Christina and Mei Ling.

    Mei Ling, To elaborate: I was paraphrasing, but what was actually said — well, written as it was in an email — was a litany of the many ways that I haven’t taken responsibility for myself. Included in that was a strong insinuation that I’m responsible for my cancer because I didn’t take care of myself prior to getting it. The entire email, which was from a now-ex-friend of almost 20 years, was written in such a cruel, vicious way that I said I never wanted to hear from her again. I’ve said — and it’s true — that I wouldn’t speak to people I don’t like how she spoke to me.

    And yes, when I was first diagnosed with breast cancer, people dismissed it as being “easily treatable.” Inflammatory Breast Cancer, which is what I have, is actually the short straw of breast cancers and not easily treatable so I consider myself extremely fortunate to have done as well as I have so far.

    Anyways, thank you for the feedback.

  3. Whoa, this touched some pain. I agree with everything you wrote here, and beautifully, I might add – but it hit something that I can’t put my finger on.

    * must think more about it *

  4. I get what you’re saying here and I’m sorry people have been dismissive of your pain. It seems people feel uncomfortable anytime someone expresses a painful truth – their first impulse is to make their own discomfort go away rather then truly listening with an open heart. “Think positive,” “everything happens for a reason,” “God will provide,” and so on….not helpful and very often quite hurtful.

    I’m very sorry you’re ill.

  5. We can never completely get what another person goes through, but we can respect it an believe it.

    That is what you are doing. That is what the weird grief that we go through can teach us, to be quieter, more respectful. That is the gift the comes from a curse.

    I am a certified cry-baby. I certified myself.

  6. Pingback: Cry-Babies « Joy’s Division

  7. This is an amazing post. It really made me think. I too am an adoptive mom and I know I will never truly understand what it is to be adopted or to have lost a child through adoption. It is a unique experience. I also hate the “angry adoptee” and “bitter birthmother” sayings – they are used far too often.

    I am truly sorry to hear how you have been marginalized in your pain with cancer. Again, I can’t understand this particular pain but I have witnessed it many times as an oncology nurse. I get what you are saying about being able to get being dismissed or marginalized without truly understanding being adopted/reliquishing a child. Mothers of special needs children (as I am) discuss this feeling often as well. People are uncomfortable with disabilities so they downplay it pointing out all your child’s strengths and telling you to focus on them as well. I have been told to “stop focusing on what he can’t do” many times or that I should be “grateful that he is so ‘high functioning’”. Or they want you to focus on “acceptance” as if I have any choice but to accept it! These people completely miss the point. It is dismissive. I just want someone to say “It isn’t fair. I’m sorry.” No one has ever said that other than my mom.

    I just found your blog but I will continue visiting!!

  8. Great post! People do seem to want to “fix” rather than just say, “sorry, that stinks” even when some things can’t really be fixed or the person isn’t asking for that.

  9. Thank you, for such a lovely post. Sometimes I wonder what ever happened to the idea of “there but for the grace of …[fill in the blank] go I?”

    I know intellectually that those who say cruel and dismissive things are actually showing their own fears and insecurities but it still hurts to be on the receiving end.

    Thank you for your compassion, and I give mine in return. I hope that you are feeling awesome these days.

  10. Pingback: what was password-protected « Just Enjoy Him

  11. Pingback: empathy deficit « Just Enjoy Him

  12. Pingback: there but for the grace of God go I « Just Enjoy Him

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s